Patrick Symmes

  • Books
    • Chasing Che
    • The Boys From Dolores
    • The Day Fidel Died
  • Articles
  • Media
    • Media
    • YouTube Videos
  • About
    • About
    • Contact
    • Sitemap
    • Author Photos
  • Books
  • Articles
  • Media
  • About

Life Under Alabama’s Harsh Immigration Law

By Patrick SymmesFebruary 6, 2012

immigration-alabama-main

A migrant worker picks tomatoes at a farm in Chandler Mountain, Ala.  Photo: Andrew Lichtenstein for Newsweek

The front door is locked on this brown-and-cream mobile home, an aluminum outpost at the end of a pine-tree trailer park beyond Birmingham, Ala. But the back door flaps open in a winter wind. Inside are a bag of red beans, some pet food, and a pair of high heels. Nothing else. Even the beds are gone. “Six people,” a neighbor says in Spanish, struggling to recall something from the anonymity of immigrant life. “Men, women, children. The law came in, and one day they just didn’t come home.”

The law: that would be H.B. 56, Alabama’s attempt at the nation’s most rigorous crackdown on illegal immigrants. On Sept. 23, 2011, when H.B. 56 came into effect, it cut off all state and local services to the undocumented. No driver’s licenses, no registration for cars, no scholarships, no hiring without a document check. Enrolling in one of Alabama’s public colleges requires proof of legal residency in the United States. Hiring, renting property to, or simply “harboring” undocumented foreigners is illegal. H.B. 56’s one-signature provision—deputizing local police officers to turn traffic stops into deportation proceedings—assumes powers long reserved to the federal government.

The law had its desired effect, sort of. Illegals did flee. Alabama reported a drop in school enrollment, especially in rural areas. This trailer and about 50 like it in a park of 300 were soon evacuated. Immigrants sold their possessions for cash and drove to Florida or California, wherever they felt safer.

But Alabama’s crackdown hasn’t played out quite as expected. A group of Mexican men unloading a pickup truck explain they fled the state, but after just a month in Florida, they came back. They pointed out an obvious irony: as H.B. 56 scared off some immigrants, others found that jobs were now going begging. And these men had now rented the same trailer for less than they paid in September.

“Alabama’s a good place,” said 51-year-old construction worker Javier Flores. “There’s all types of people.”

If Alabama is the GOP’s latest front in the war on illegal immigration, then the battle is far from won. The tired and poor, the huddled masses, are still here, yearning to rent cheap and work hard. All the crackdown in Alabama has done is push people deeper into the woodwork. Yet immigrants remain everywhere in Alabama, hiding in plain sight, evading the crackdown with GPS strategies and shared text alerts. Family networks and the surprising kindness of strangers have given them camouflage.

In this tense environment, immigrants drive slowly and stay low. “We couldn’t be more hidden,” one man says.

In short, the law is immensely popular—and it’s not working very well. It has disrupted business in Alabama, and enforcement is proving costly. The state legislature last week began work on modifying the law.

But modify only. “It won’t be repealed,” says a confident Gov. Robert J. Bentley, a Republican from Tuscaloosa. In one poll, 73 percent of Alabamans supported H.B. 56; Bentley notes that the measure is almost as popular nationally. “I never go on television without getting asked about it,” he says.

Bentley, a physician who began working at the state capital in his 20s, calls federal policy a “failure” that requires Alabama to step in and “uphold the state and federal constitutions.”

Besides, there’s not much percentage in a Republican letting up on the issue. When Newt Gingrich suggested in a November debate that “immigration policy which destroys families” was a bad thing, he walked into a buzz saw of retribution from some conservatives. Last year state legislatures weighed 1,600 bills against illegal immigrants, and passed 300 of them, a populist wave that predates Occupy Wall Street and the Tea Party and has a powerful grip on both parties.

Like earlier attempts in Arizona and South Carolina, most of these state immigration laws were blocked by courts; the U.S. Constitution reserved enforcement of the borders to the feds. Alabama H.B. 56 has provoked suits by everyone from the Birmingham Catholic Diocese to the Justice Department.

H.B. 56’s very success has stirred moral qualms among Alabamans that could weaken or even undo it. “Jesus Was an Anchor Baby,” declared one sign at a recent march on the governor’s mansion, and State Sen. Billy Beasley compared H.B. 56 to the racial segregation of Alabama’s scarred past. “I know in my heart,” he told the protesters, “that Jesus Christ would not support what is happening in Alabama.”

And then there is an even higher law—supply and demand. Whatever H.B. 56 says, picking tomatoes in Alabama pays about eight times as much as it does in Baja.

Most studies calculate that illegal immigration boosts the American economy. Many immigrants contribute to Social Security without being eligible to draw on it. But the net gain in jobs is an abstraction compared with Alabama’s low wages and stubborn unemployment, which ran more than 9 percent before the bill. Sponsors of H.B. 56 took credit for a subsequent decline to 8.7 percent unemployment, saying legal workers were getting the jobs of departed illegals. But there has been an economic cost, with tomatoes rotting unpicked on the side of Chandler Mountain, and agriculture and the service sector “devastated,” according to the Southern Poverty Law Center. Even Governor Bentley acknowledges “some pain, in the short term.”

Deepak Bhargava, executive director for the Center for Community Change, says Alabama has only itself to blame. For years the state gave “a wink and a nod” to imported labor and “essentially offered an invitation to bring labor in, to work, and to build families. For them now to persecute the same families is the height of hypocrisy.”

immigration-alabama-secondary

Hundreds turned out for a pro-immigration rally on the governor’s lawn in December. Photo: Andrew Lichtenstein for Newsweek

It’s not just about tomatoes, either. Local police jailed a German executive from the Mercedes-Benz plant in Tuscaloosa, and another checkpoint snagged a Japanese worker at Honda’s $1.4 billion plant. Both incidents “did grievous harm to Alabama’s reputation,” Bhargava notes. Governor Bentley has found himself assuring Chinese and other foreign investors that Alabama welcomes not just foreign investment but foreign investors.

Are the toilet cleaners welcome? Carla and Ruben hide behind drawn blinds every night. They are Costa Ricans who ask to be called by new names. The apartment is cozy; their three handsome sons sit patiently on a white sofa. The couple is educated and middle class but got stuck cleaning toilets for cash in an underground economy. They work to provide for their family, they say, but haven’t seen their own parents in 16 years.

Survival in Alabama 2.0: one shopping trip a week, to minimize exposure to the police. A carpool to St. Francis Xavier for the 1 p.m. mass in Spanish. (Parking at the church is easy since H.B. 56; one third of the lot is suddenly free.) When they set out in the morning, they remind their sons—the youngest a U.S. citizen—not to panic if they disappear. Move to your aunt’s apartment, the parents say. Stay in school. We’ll call you when we land in Costa Rica.

The couple recalls one of the houses they clean weekly. The owner is a “really important” figure in Alabama whom they won’t identify. “He speaks against Latinos,” Carla notes, “but hires Latinos to clean his house.” The man threatened to fire them if they were illegals—then dropped the matter. If H.B. 56 sputters out, it may be because people in Alabama want a clean house more than they want to clean house.

via Newsweek: Life Under Alabama’s Harsh Immigration Law.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Newsweek Tagged: Billy Beasley, Chandler Mountain, Deepak Bhargava, GOP, Javier Flores, State Sen, United States, USA

Primary Sidebar

HELLO. I am a writer, journalist and teacher.

Profile Image I cover insurgencies, global environmental problems, travel, and the geopolitical fault lines that underlie them all, for magazines like Harper’s, Outside, and Condé Nast Traveler... [Continue reading]

Articles

  • How to Make Friends with Strangers
  • The Day Fidel Died
  • The Ancient Ruins Terror Can’t Destroy
  • NO DEAL, a look at Obama’s reluctant partners inside Cuba
  • The Cuban Money Crisis
  • Harper’s Video: The Cuban State Diet
  • The Real Rebels of Timbuktu
  • Slow Food and Agritourism in the Pacific Northwest
  • Cuba’s Rising Art Scene
  • YouTube Videos
  • Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea
  • Off the Deep End
  • The Sweetest Villains
  • The Beautiful Game: Soccer Violence
  • Blue Beauty
  • Life Under Alabama’s Harsh Immigration Law
  • Sand Storm: Yemen on the Brink
  • Path of Dreams: The Trip of a Lifetime in Uganda
  • Anwar al-Awlaki: The Next Bin Laden
  • Earth Beat – Footprints: Who pinched my ride?
  • Chasing Che
  • The Boys From Dolores XX
  • Immersion Therapy—Interview with Anderson Cooper
  • Agritourism in the Pacific Northwest (PDF)
  • Fresh Air: South Sudan
  • The Filthy, Fecund Secret of Emilia-Romagna
  • Turkey: Archeological Dig Reshaping Human History
  • Rafting the Yangtze River, China
  • China Lost & Found
  • Unnatural Disaster
  • The Cabin of My Dreams
  • Playground of the Gods
  • Thirty Days as a Cuban
  • A Wild Country Grows in South Sudan
  • City on the Edge
  • Sleepless in Stockholm
  • Writers Voice: Cuba Present And Past
  • Dispatches – cbc radio: The Cuban State Diet
  • New Tactics for an Old Regime in Cuba
  • Dams in Chilean Patagonia
  • Meet The Neighbors
  • Day of Ascension
  • Hugo’s World
  • The Ghost of Shipwrecks Future

Search

Publications

  • AFAR Magazine (1)
  • Bloomberg Business (1)
  • Condé Nast Traveler (8)
  • GQ (1)
  • Harper's (1)
  • New York Times Opinion (1)
  • New York Times T Magazine (1)
  • Newsweek (3)
  • Outside Magazine (17)
  • Yahoo News (1)
  • My Books

    CHASING CHE:A Motorcycle Journey in Search of the Guevara Legend. Available on Amazon

    CHASING CHE
    A Motorcycle Journey in Search of the Guevara Legend

    Available on Amazon

    THE BOYS FROM DOLORES: Fidel Castro's Schoolmates From Revolution to Exile. Available on Amazon

    THE BOYS FROM DOLORES
    Fidel Castro's Schoolmates From Revolution to Exile

    Available on Amazon

    e-books

    THE DAY FIDEL DIED: Cuba in the Age of Raul, Obama, and the Rolling Stones Available on Amazon

    THE DAY FIDEL DIED:
    Cuba in the Age of Raúl, Obama, and the Rolling Stones

    Available on Amazon for $0.99

    Footer

    Featured Articles

    Agritourism in the Pacific Northwest (PDF)

    Download PDF Published in Condé Nast Traveler Slow Food and Agritourism in the Pacific Northwest … [Continue reading] about Agritourism in the Pacific Northwest (PDF)

    The Herbfarm's model garden of raised beds supplies ingredients for the restaurant’s dishes.

    Slow Food and Agritourism in the Pacific Northwest

    Written by: Patrick Symmes and Peter Frank Edwards Harvest Swoon It's called agriturismo in Italy—travel to the things that feed us—but these days it's blooming right here at home, especially in the … [Continue reading] about Slow Food and Agritourism in the Pacific Northwest

    Blue Grotto, Saipan

    Blue Beauty

    Belize, Bonaire, and the Bahamas share more than a first letter—they are among the best places in the greater Caribbean to experience that increasingly imperiled wonder of the world, the tropical … [Continue reading] about Blue Beauty

    Ugandan gorilla

    Path of Dreams: The Trip of a Lifetime in Uganda

    We shared a room at the Hotel Diplomate in Kampala, Uganda, which was slightly awkward. Despite nearly a decade of email and scratchy Skyping, years of sending hope and Western Union transfers across … [Continue reading] about Path of Dreams: The Trip of a Lifetime in Uganda

    • Blue Beauty
    • Life Under Alabama’s Harsh Immigration Law
    • Sand Storm: Yemen on the Brink
    • Path of Dreams: The Trip of a Lifetime in Uganda
    • Anwar al-Awlaki: The Next Bin Laden
    • Earth Beat – Footprints: Who pinched my ride?

    Archives

    • October 2017 (2)
    • May 2015 (1)
    • April 2015 (1)
    • March 2015 (1)
    • August 2014 (1)
    • May 2014 (1)
    • April 2014 (1)
    • April 2013 (2)
    • March 2013 (1)
    • February 2013 (1)
    • December 2012 (1)
    • November 2012 (1)
    • October 2012 (1)
    • February 2012 (2)
    • July 2011 (2)
    • May 2011 (1)
    • March 2011 (1)
    • October 2010 (4)
    • July 2010 (2)
    • June 2010 (1)
    • February 2010 (1)
    • September 2009 (1)
    • August 2009 (1)
    • March 2009 (1)
    • November 2008 (1)
    • October 2008 (1)
    • September 2008 (1)
    • May 2008 (1)
    • October 2007 (1)
    • March 2007 (2)
    • February 2006 (1)
    • September 2005 (1)
    • April 2002 (1)
    • January 2002 (1)
    • April 2001 (1)

    Random Quote

    Brilliant… Symmes is a staccato historian, a storyteller… also a superb journalist.Washington Post

    Tags

    Acosta (1) Adventure Travel Edition (1) Al Qaeda (1) Anderson Cooper (1) AQAP (1) Arabian Peninsula (1) Arda Valley (1) Argentina (4) Asia (3) Audio (4) Beijing (1) Beijing Olympics (1) Betty Ford (1) Billy Beasley (1) Black South Africans (1) Blue Beauty (1) Boston Globe (1) Brazil Mato Grosso (1) Caribbean (3) Carl Safina (1) Carretera Austral (1) CBC (1) Central African Republic (1) Chandler Mountain (1) Chile (1) Chilean Patagonia (1) China (1) China Institute (1) Chris Pala (1) Congo (1) Cuba (5) Cuba/Caribbean (3) Cuban President Ra (1) CUC (1) Deepak Bhargava (1) East African (1) Easter Island (1) Ed Norton (1) England (1) Ernesto Che Guevara (1) Europe (2) Europe/Africa (6) European Cape Town (1) European Union (1) Every Cuban (1) Explorers Club (1) FBI (1) FEMA (1) Fertile Crescent (1) Fidel Castro (2) First World (1) Forest Service (1) friends (1) Gaucho Charley (1) George Bass (1) Glenn Schwartz (1) Golden Week (1) GOP (1) GPS (2) Great Bend (1) Great Inagua (1) Greece (1) Guillermo Fari (1) Gulf Stream (1) haiti (1) Harper Magazine (1) Havana Nocturne (1) Ice Age (1) Imatong Falls (1) Imperial Guard (1) Interviews (1) Italy (1) Italy Let (1) Jacques Cauvin (1) Javier Flores (1) Johns Hopkins (1) Kris Tompkins (1) La Doce (1) Lady Carolina (1) Lake Maracaibo (1) Lake Titicaca (1) Land Rover (1) Laos (1) La Paz (1) Lebanon (1) Long Street (1) Los Roques (1) Maduro (1) Maracaibo City (1) Marco Polo (1) Marcus Samuelsson (1) Marnie Chesterton (1) meeting neighbors (1) Mesoamerican Reef (1) Michael Hanson (1) Middle East (2) Middle East (2) MININT (1) Mother City (1) Mountain Travel Sobek (1) Mount Kinyeti (1) National Tea Museum (1) Nature Conservancy (1) New Jersey (2) New York (2) New York City (2) New York Times (1) New Zealand (1) NOAA (1) Obama (1) Old City (2) Old Scandinavia (1) Old Town (1) Orient Express (1) Patrick Otim (1) Peru (1) Petersburg Times (1) Possibly Chile (1) Po Valley (1) Rat Stabbers (1) Raúl (1) Red Sea (1) Robben Island (1) Shining Path (1) Sofitel West Lake (1) South America (7) South Sudan (1) South Sudanese (1) South Yemen (1) State Sen (1) Steve Nagiewicz (1) Stockholm Gamla Stan (1) strangers (1) sweden (1) Sylvia Earle (1) Syria (1) Table Mountain (1) Team Sawyer (1) Tiger Leaping Gorge (1) TNC (1) Today Turkish (1) Top Tree Houses (1) traveling (1) turkey (1) Turquoise Coast (1) TV (1) Uganda Wildlife Authority (1) UK (1) UNESCO (1) United States (1) Unnatural Disaster (1) US (1) USA (4) venezuela (1) Venezuela Map (1) Video (2) Washington Post (1) WCS (1) Windward Passage (1) Writer Patrick Symmes (1) Wushan Square (1) yemen (1) Yet Bolivians (1)

    Menu

    • Books
      • Chasing Che
      • The Boys From Dolores
      • The Day Fidel Died
    • Articles
    • Media
      • Media
      • YouTube Videos
    • About
      • About
      • Contact
      • Sitemap
      • Author Photos

    Return to top of page
    © 2025 Patrick Symmes · All Rights Reserved · Site by Forever Ink · Log in